How would X win in a fight against Y

[SINIB]

Just look at Shirou. A man among men.

i don't think Shirou would eat Hisui's cooking.
Considering putting oyster sauce on his yams physically hurt him.

[Kat]

Kiritsugu vs Kairi, scenario outside of HGW so no Avalon for the former.

[SINIB]

Straight fight?

[Kat]

Generally what a freelancer would do against another freelancer. Both don't play fair.

[SINIB]

I think kiritsugu then, assuming prep.

[LostHanyou]

Arnold Schwarzenegger as the Terminator lands in an alien-infested Nostromo from the movie Alien. He must go through an alien queen and a number of regular aliens before the ship reaches earths orbit.  Does he succeed?

[Kat]

*cough* Type-Moon *cough*

[SINIB]

Who's this?

[Kat]

Some random almost lurker? I don't recognize him.

[Kat]

Given it was brought up in Apo thread.

Mordred vs Rider (Shinji and Sakura ones separately discussed)

[Cherry Lover]

Some random almost lurker? I don't recognize him.

He's a guy who was on the old DSM, and who hasn't been around for ages.

Given it was brought up in Apo thread.

Mordred vs Rider (Shinji and Sakura ones separately discussed)

Well, for one thing, how powerful is Mordred's master? It does matter. For example, Rider under Sakura could give Saber under Shirou a good fight and quite possibly defeat her, but she would lose pretty easily against Saber under Rin.

[Kat]

He is pretty good, a freelancer necromancer that uses firearms and ammo crafted with his magecraft from a legitimate magus family, so he inherited his Crest through normal means.

As for stats:

Shirou!Saber:

Strength:   B  Endurance: C Agility: C Mana: B Luck: B   N. Phantasm: C

Rin!Saber:

Strength:   A  Endurance: B Agility: B Mana: A Luck: A+ N. Phantasm: A++

Mordred:

Strength:   B+  Endurance: A Agility: B Mana: B Luck: D N. Phantasm: A+

For reference Mordred has an anti-unit C rank NP, anti-army beamu A+, Instinct B, Prana Burst A, Battle Continuation B, Magic Resistance B, Riding B and Charisma C-

[Cherry Lover]

Hmm, well, it sounds like Mordred would almost certainly beat Shinji Rider. I really have no clue about Sakura Rider, though. We don't see her fight very much, and I have no idea of what Mordred is actually capable of.

[SINIB]

Mordred is a based badass, she'd probably demolish Sakura Rider.

[LostHanyou]

*cough* Type-Moon *cough*

Sorry, forgot The Terminator and Alien weren't made by Type-Moon for a minute there.  Small lapse in thought.

Who's this?

The hero DSM needs.

More relevantly, Mordred and Rider are tied in the fashion competition - Mordred's armor certainly looks cooler than Rider's stripper outfit, but how can one compete against sweater Rider?  Certainly not with a mere tube top!  However, in battle it probably depends on if Clarent can beat Bellerophon, though Rider also technically has a lot more versatility with the mount.