Lantz's fanfiction round up and discussion

[lantzblades]

I intended zero to occur, with the exception of Kiritsugu to happen identically as canon.

I don't think Shirou would be too different other then Ilya being saved by Kiritsugu giving him a sister.

and trust or not do you have a better idea then the church given that both her birth parents are dead and rin was basically raised by Kirei, at least legally

[Cherry Lover]

I intended zero to occur, with the exception of Kiritsugu to happen identically as canon.

That doesn't make sense if Ciel rescues Sakura, though. That would significantly change Kariya's actions.

I don't think Shirou would be too different other then Ilya being saved by Kiritsugu giving him a sister.

Hmm, I see.

and trust or not do you have a better idea then the church given that both her birth parents are dead and rin was basically raised by Kirei, at least legally

Not obviously, but the Church seems like a terrible idea to me. Aside from her not having any real parents or family, there's no reason she'd be in the area. And, they aren't generally the sort of people who I would trust to raise a kid, they just seem to see people as tools, especially a powerful magus.

[lantzblades]

That doesn't make sense if Ciel rescues Sakura, though. That would significantly change Kariya's actions.

it means the rescue happens post war.

but the Church seems like a terrible idea to me. Aside from her not having any real parents or family, there's no reason she'd be in the area. And, they aren't generally the sort of people who I would trust to raise a kid, they just seem to see people as tools, especially a powerful magus.

the church is more then that.

[Cherry Lover]

That doesn't make sense if Ciel rescues Sakura, though. That would significantly change Kariya's actions.

it means the rescue happens post war.

Ah, OK.

but the Church seems like a terrible idea to me. Aside from her not having any real parents or family, there's no reason she'd be in the area. And, they aren't generally the sort of people who I would trust to raise a kid, they just seem to see people as tools, especially a powerful magus.

the church is more then that.

Well, yeah, sure, but the issue with them not being in the area still holds true.

[lantzblades]

Well, yeah, sure, but the issue with them not being in the area still holds true.

she'd be with kirei

[Cherry Lover]

Well, yeah, sure, but the issue with them not being in the area still holds true.

she'd be with kirei

Erm, but Kirei's idea of how to treat an orphan is to lock them up in the basement and let Gil feed off them....

[lantzblades]

normally but not in sakura's case.

[Cherry Lover]

normally but not in sakura's case.

Why would she be different?

And, how would he raise her? He's not someone who is generally inclined towards raising children, after all, and certainly not in a nice way. Indeed, where would she live?

[lantzblades]

Sakura is markedly different then normal kids remember she's Rin's sister which means kotomine would as per canon take advantage of that to revel in the suffering

[Cherry Lover]

Sakura is markedly different then normal kids remember she's Rin's sister which means kotomine would as per canon take advantage of that to revel in the suffering

Well, yes, true. That's hardly good for Sakura, though, or for Rin for that matter....

[lantzblades]

to a point, although it makes it interesting

[Cherry Lover]

to a point, although it makes it interesting

Well, it depends what you mean by "interesting"....

[lantzblades]

different from the usual, open to interesting developments.

[Cherry Lover]

different from the usual, open to interesting developments.

Yes, I mean what the effect of it would be. In particular, how would Kotomine be treating Sakura, and what would her relationship with Rin be?

[lantzblades]

I imagine like Rin except that he'd have her as a sister in the church.