Show Posts
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
Well, it's a matter of secrecy. To be a Heroic Spirit, you have to be known about, and Shiki isn't. I think it is unlikely that Shirou would become well-known enough to do it, but not necessarily impossible (if some sort of big magical war were to happen, for example). And, as Lantz has pointed out previously, if something is possible, however unlikely, then the fact that the Nasuverse is a Multiverse means that it probably has happened somewhere.Sure. In some reality maybe the AoG lasted longer and Shirou became a HS that way but it wouldn't be Emiya Shirou. Wouldn't be the kid that participated in the 5th GW. Even if there was a full blown war there are still people there are many people in the Nasuverse more important and famous than Shirou. There is nothing unique or original about Shirou other than his RM and there are several people with that as well. In fact even UBW is copying other weapons. Nothing about him is unique enough to be HS material.
I'm not saying that Shirou has become a HS somewhere, but I don't think we can absolutely 100% rule it out. It's just not something that is likely to happen very often if at all.
Again, that is simply not true. At absolute most, Many-Worlds theory means that anything that is possible will happen in some universe (and even that isn't certain, because there has to be some set of quantum events that could lead to it). It certainly does not make the impossible possible. Even if you have an infinite number of worlds, something that has literally zero chance of happening will still happen in none of them.Well for becoming a HS Shirou would have to do something important enough to become a legend. He would also need to have been lived during the time Jack the Ripper, Li, or the AoG since modern day people cannot become HS. Even people with completely unique abilities or magecraft like Zeltretch or Aoko cannot be HS and Tracing is not on the level of the True Magics.
Nasu said only heroes can get there and LE Shirou is heavily implied to not have become a CG, far as I'm concerned that closes the book on the idea, he's there, so obviously he's a heroic spirit.I'm pretty sure that people from the modern era cannot become a HS unless they become CGs. So if only heroes could be there then it is impossible for Shirou to enter Avalon.
