@ Cherry:
Eh, what? Where did you get the idea it was "filled with shadows" from?
Don't trust me on that, since I vaguely remember reading something to that effect on the wiki. "Taking it into the shadow realm and spearing people with the shadows" or something.
But the soul isn't "destroyed" in the process of doing so, since the eventual result of the Grail War would have been the souls of the heroes returning to Akasha and, in the process, punching a hole that could be opened wider to allow the magus performing the ritual to get there.
So the reason the Heroic Spirits are retained is so that when there are enough of them, the effect of 6/7 of these huge souls getting back to the Root at once would open a big enough hole for shit to happen? If so, then I've been misunderstanding the process this entire time.
Yeah, I'm not sure you even could "dissect" a soul. I believe the soul is actually indestructable.
IIRC, when a person dies their soul returns to Akasha and is torn apart, wiped of all information and the bits are reused. Souls are definitely indestructable, but they can seemingly be divided and wiped clean.
ATTW, it says that the soul is indestructible in the
material realm, but that the soul usually resides somewhere else that's between the Root and "reality", meaning that someone could conceivably start ripping it apart if they could access this space-between-spaces (lol).
@ Willy
Albeit I like to think about them as "telomers" of the "soul string". Something which is only fabricated when a person exists in the physical world.
And breaks down completely once that lost its usefulness.
Astral genetics, basically. If I'm interpreting this correctly, then a persona is only there to protect the soul-core from damage, so if there's a mental attack, then the persona breaks before the soul-core does.
This is also the reason why not every human has magic circuits. It's a kind of leftover trait and modern humans should have no need of it.
Ohh, so they're becoming vestigial. As a species, we don't really use them anymore, so they've fallen by the wayside.
Long story short magic is something that progressively becomes less necessary to humans.
So it's spiritual devolution by material evolution, with the increase of what we consider "possible" leading to the rapid decrease in what we consider "impossible", destroying the sense of wonder which was the reason why olde Magick was so damn powerful?
Also, Magicians technically aren't human anymore, right? They're treated as their own independent entities (that Akasha wants to destroy), unless I miss my guess.
This is most likely also the reason why magi dwelves to much into the past instead of just trying to develop better uses for their current magic.
Because they don't like being made obsolete.
Wait, okay, so could this potentially be how Reality Marbles work? You make a copy of your persona and overwrite the outside world with it temporarily. That's why you can't get it through rote study or pass it on, as everyone's persona is completely different.