of flesh and fantasy poll and discussion.

[Cherry Lover]

No one is taken yet

As far as I am concerned, Shirou is taken. I'm not letting Sakura get dumped because Saber can't be paired with anyone else, and she has the exact same problem anyway.

[lantzblades]

I said we needed to discuss them. If you're not going to follow along then fine, we'll see about another idea

[Cherry Lover]

I said we needed to discuss them. If you're not going to follow along then fine, we'll see about another idea

Yeah, sure we need to discuss it, but aside from the fact that this issue comes up every single time we discuss pairings and will continue to come up every time we discuss pairings, if we pair Shirou with Saber then we hit the exact same problem with Sakura.

[lantzblades]

It's not about just those two, others girls like shirou, hell rider like shirou we need to fairly consider them all

[Cherry Lover]

Look, there is no way to "fairly" consider them all. There is no fair way to pick any one girl over the others, and even if there was it would guarentee the same pairing every time. We have to pick a girl and then go with that.

[lantzblades]

The fairness is in the discussion. And really there are fans of others like ayako,caster etcetera

[Cherry Lover]

The fairness is in the discussion.

The thing is, there is still no way to be "fair". Because there is no way to choose a girl that isn't going to lead to us arguing over who deserves Shirou the most or whatever.

Also, it does seem pointless to ask me for ideas if my suggestions have no bearing on the final outcome. Why not just say "let's discuss it" and put forward options...?

And really there are fans of others like ayako,caster etcetera

Sure, then go ask them for ideas, or suggest them yourself....

[lantzblades]

Ok, discussion is dead here so  let us just drop it  and move on to something else

[Cherry Lover]

Well, OK, I understand what you wanted a bit better now. So, I'm going to suggest a couple of couples, and dynamics for each of them. The first is Shirou x Sakura, who are the nice couple. The second is Rin x Archer, who are the argumentative couple, who bicker and troll each other all the time.

[lantzblades]

Rin and archer wouldn't be the arguing  couple but ok we can work with this

[Cherry Lover]

Rin and archer wouldn't be the arguing  couple but ok we can work with this

Well, OK, what do you think their dynamic would be? I mean, arguing, trolling each other etc. seems pretty much normal for those two....

[lantzblades]

They are the interesting couple, playful and witty, they are social opposites with clear sexual chemistry

[Cherry Lover]

They are the interesting couple, playful and witty, they are social opposites with clear sexual chemistry

Yeah, OK, that definitely fits. Although it's kind-of what I was trying to convey....

[lantzblades]

We need the trouble makers, the wild girl and guy she's with and other personalities

[Cherry Lover]

We need the trouble makers, the wild girl and guy she's with and other personalities

Hmm, well, what would Rider and Toshi count as? I'm not sure enough of Toshi's personality to say....