General Nasuverse Lore/Character/Serious Canon Discussion Thread

[RamKingSpaceSlamKatsulam]

Sorry, but you have provided zero evidence of that statement. I have provided reasons why it isn't, now it is your turn to provide actual evidence that what you are saying is compatible with what is shown in the VN.

Remind me, I forgot and I jumped in in the middle of the argument anyways. 

[Kat]

I have this feeling Cherry Lover is in denial over parts of side materials and Nasu's interviews he doesn't like.

[Cherry Lover]

I have this feeling Cherry Lover is in denial over parts of side materials and Nasu's interviews he doesn't like.

No, I just consider the actual VN to take priority.

[The Man With All The Cute Boats]

Wow this isn't rocket science

Archer/Shirou cannot trace Excalibur(WoG): they can make something that looks like it and farts rainbows, but it's straight up not excalibur. It's like if you look at a statue you thought was made of, I dunno, copper online and then you made a statue that sorta looked like copper, but the original was made of bronze. You didn't copy it successfully, but you created something that looks like it, yet that's all it really does: look like it.

Note that I have no idea if you can make statues out of copper or whatever shit

[Alice]

You can make statues out of copper, actually. The Statue of Liberty is actually copper. That's why it's green now, that's what happens to copper when it's exposed to so much oxygen and turns into copper oxide.

But yup, as for the rest, that's pretty much it in a nutshell. ...I just felt like being pedantic about the copper thing. :V

[Kat]

Excalibur image is simply even shittier than his ordinary Projections, and probably drain too much EMIYA in non-Moon Cell settings.

[Cherry Lover]

Yeah, that's the impression I get. It's the best he can do with what he is capable of reading of Excalibur, but because he can't really comprehend the fairy parts of it he can't do anything like as good a job as he usually would.

[Kat]

Topic: Did worms ate Sakura's uterus or placenta? I get both answers from various people.

[Cherry Lover]

Topic: Did worms ate Sakura's uterus or placenta? I get both answers from various people.

To the first, I'm pretty sure the answer is "no". Zouken's intentions for her included having her produce an heir for him, and if the worms ate her uterus that would be impossible. To the second, the answer is "not unless she somehow became pregnant at some point", since women don't have a placenta unless they're pregnant....

[Umbra of Chaos]

So she is either pregnant or Nasu doesn't know anatomy.

[Cherry Lover]

What?

[Kat]

Placenta is formed when fetus forms.

[Cherry Lover]

Yeah, what I mean is that I'm not sure why we have to assume that Zouken's worms ate a placenta Sakura had at some point. I think it's said that they do like eating placentas, but that doesn't imply Sakura ever had one.

[Umbra of Chaos]

Edit: Maybe it's better just to leave it be. I'll PM you about it Mike.

[Kat]

Is it impossible for non-DA human to stay thousands of years alive without his soul rotting?