His left hand idly ruffling the child who thanked him's hair, Karna faced the woman with a dominating presence once more.
"However, according to your logic, M'lord, what the child is doing is effectively what you are accusing everyone here. Is she, by taking the lives of others seeking their own path, actually worse than what you are accusing Forest and the strega here of doing?" She idly gestured to Henry as almost an afterthought. "At least they are not ending anyone's existence, which is far the worse crime than trying to convince someone of a more suitable way to pursue their goals."
"You would be correct. However, this is merely me arrogantly picking a side, something all living beings will have to do some day. I picked the side of the killer, the side that must accept death the moment they inflict it upon another. I cannot claim to be neutral, that would require me to be a hopeless man with no attachment to other humans; Something that would be end in beautiful tragedy, but could be barely be considered human. "
"But even if Amelia kills a great number of people, each of those, provided they lived a life of good actions, will one day be rewarded in their next."
"By choosing to let Amelia do as she wishes, I am in part responsible for everything she does. That shall then be my fate. Hate me if you want to, Forest, Henry, but I am merely doing what I see as right in the situation at hand."
With that, he was done. There was nothing more to say. Karna would selfishly choose the child who would murder those who practiced the arcane arts simply because she was currently in danger. He understood the hypocrisy of his actions, but he did not show it.
Amelia
Amelia looked around as the woman and the man began to leave. Both seemingly frustrated.
“Umm… can I go then? I need to go make graves.” She looked down almost in shame, “M-master said I shouldn’t mourn them, but… The purpose he left me was only to hunt, not to let them die without a farewell…”
She then heard a yell come from upstairs making her look at the ceiling, "What was that sound? Is someone hurt?"
Taking a hold of Amelia's shoulders and staring deep into her eyes, Karna responded to her question.
"Go now, Amelia, and make alms for your actions. Bury and honor those you have killed, and see if in your heart you can still not feel compassion for those you cut down. Look at their graves when you are done and ask yourself this; Is this dream even what I wanted?"
Then he responded to her second question, an almost comical reversal of order.
"As for the noise just now, it is merely the act of premarital copulation."