So, from what I've heard on /a/ most people think this will be shit.
Opinions from everyone?
Well, it seems pretty obvious from what they've said previously that they intend to try to involve all of the major characters from every route, and most likely give them a good ending as well. I don't personally think that makes it "shit", but I suspect that a lot of people will see it that way, and I also agree that there is a real danger of them making a right mess of it, like Deen did.
And, honestly, the most likely alternative is another damn adaptation of Fate, which frankly is not something we need, and thus will be shit anyway. A pure adaptation of Fate is just boring, we already know what goes on and it's not far off from the Deen anime (just without filler), and any attempt to add scenes for Sakura, Rider and Archer will need to be done a
lot better than Deen's frankly-pathetic attempt.