Well, yes, true, but I would like it not to be confined to only those characters.
didn't say it was.
No, fair enough, but designing situations in which some characters do BDSM stuff (especially with someone like Shirou as the dom) is quite hard.
More to the point, though, I don't get to provide any assistance to that. Which, aside from meaning I can't suggest pairings or scenes I'd like to see, also means that I have no way to actually contribute to the discussion in the thread.
Well, sure they wouldn't like it, but nor does Shirou, so I don't see the problem.
given Saber's stubbornness I do see a problem, a big problem.
What problem, exactly? What is she going to do? Tell him to free Sakura and Rin (he can't, and they wouldn't want to leave
anyway)? Tell him to try to overthrow the system (he is already)?
The problem is that you say that for every idea I have. Which defeats the damn point of me even bothering to contribute....
this was bad luck.
In what way was it "bad luck"? Did you roll a dice to test if it passed or something?
If not, then luck had bugger all to do with it. You just didn't like the concept. And, if it was something about the concept that could be changed without getting rid of the stuff I actually
want, then you'd have done so, or at least
tried.
So, the only reasonable conclusion is that it's fundamental principle behind what I was aiming for that you object to (which is borne out by the way you're talking about it), which means it seems pointless for me to try anything like this again. It'll only get rejected again.
I'm running out of concepts to suggest. You're already seriously limiting the field by insisting it not be dark (I went through three or four concepts in my head before I suggested this one), and now you're limiting it further by rejecting things like this. There is simply nothing left, because everything will either end up as too dark or too squicky (like a universe in which people
want to be slaves).
