Things That Annoy You in Fanfiction

[KAIZA]

Actually, I believe the better idea here would be to just drop the topic, since making another thread for it will just end up as a repeat of previous events.

So, please, let's just move on to another topic.

[Xamusel]

Works for me.

So... back to things that annoy people in Fanfiction?

[lantzblades]

Repeat the war cliché (Not in the sense of pre fate but post) and the keeping Ilya a child thing, look I get it that her body is messed up but when it can reasonably be fixed then just do it.

[Xamusel]

Hmm... you get annoyed by 6th Grail War fics? Is that what I'm hearing from you?

[Kat]

Wanting to repair Ilya's body is a canon revisionism which I oppose.

[Cherry Lover]

Why? We know it's possible to do such things, because Shirou gets a puppet body at the end of HF, and the impression I get from what she says in HF is that Ilya's problem is with her body and not her soul, so she should be able to get a "proper" body and grow into a true adult.

Nasu also does hint at the idea of Ilya finding a way to survive post-Fate in the Hot Springs episode, so it's not really "canon revisionism" to do so. Nasu himself never ruled it out.

[Kat]

I simply don't want any risk of flanderizing her into second Iri, because Iri is boring.

[Cherry Lover]

I think that having her as an eternal child would be even worse, honestly. It prevents her having much if any character development, because everyone will always see her as a little kid.

And, actually, Ilya is probably more mature than Iri is. She still acts somewhat childish, yes, but she shows she is capable of being serious when necessary.

[lantzblades]

Iri is a bit dull but then fate zero was as a whole imo. Prequels suck the fun out. And want Ilya to have a body is not revisionism, it's progression, if she lives then making her body work normally is honestly a matter of course, if not, well, enjoy your dead loli I guess.

[Kat]

People who want adult Ilya just want h-doujins of her without lolicon baggage, hue.

[lantzblades]

Not everyone X, I just want her to be able to be normal

[Kat]

She is a homunculus, so she never will be.

[Cherry Lover]

That's not really true. Sure, she's never going to just be a normal human, but nor are Rin or Sakura. That doesn't mean she can't have a reasonably "normal" life.

[lantzblades]

X you're being needlessly literal and bleak

[Arch-Magos Winter]

X you're being needlessly literal and bleak

So telling the truth and being rational about it is a horrible thing?

Ilya is pretty much fated to die young. That's a given.